A federal judge sentenced Ruben Verastigui, 29, of . He was sentenced by the Honorable Amit P. Mehta. According to the Daily Beast, Homeland Security agents uncovered a website that at least 18 people were using to share child pornography. A former Republican Senate and Republican National Committee employee Ruben Verastigui was arrested at his Washington, DC home for child pornography. In one exchange Verastigui allegedly wrote, Well like I said babies are some of my biggest turn-ons and beast. Verastigui then allegedly asked the person who sent him the videos to come to DC for the purpose of sexually abusing a minor.. Jerry Lambe is a journalist at Law&Crime. Federal prosecutors have revealed new and even more disturbing details in their case against Ruben A. Verastigui, a former Senate Republican Conference aide who was charged on Saturday with distributing, receiving and possessing child pornography for 11 months leading up to February. In a statement of facts entered with the plea agreement, Verastigui agreed he told investigators that he was Landon and that he used the internet to view, receive and share child porn among the group. 13. Previously a reporter for Courthouse News, he has appeared as a guest on NewsNation, NBC, MSNBC, CBS's "Inside Edition," BBC, NPR, PBS, Sky News, and other networks. Verastigui was sentenced on the same day the Senate confirmed Ketanji Brown Jackson as Supreme Court justice, whom Republicans tried to discredit by misleadingly depicting her as lenient on child pornography offenses. In 2020, there were 618,399 victims of child abuse in the U.S. Contact Information. Ruben A. Verastigui, who worked for tRUMP and the GOP in 2017 to 2020, posted a photo of himself at the White House beside an ornate Christmas tree and under a doorway with the Presidential . Ruben Verastigui of Washington, D.C., pleaded guilty to charges of having 162 videos and more than 50 images of child pornography on his phone in July 2021. Chat logs show he and another group member talked about traveling somewhere with few cops so they could kill a child, the memo says. 1,749 posts. Have a tip or story idea? Or to keep it anonymous, click here. He also wrote that he designed social media creative and digital ads for the Trump Make America Great Again Committee and Donald J. Trump for President, Inc., After about a year with the RNC, Verastigui took a job with the Senate. 404. It wasnt immediately clear whether he had retained a lawyer. Verastigui's LinkedIn shows he worked for the Senate Republican Conference until July. How many people are missing here today because of abortion?. WASHINGTON - Ruben Verastigui, 29, of Washington, D.C., was sentenced today to 151 months in prison on a federal charge of receipt of child pornography. During an interview with investigators, Verastigui admitted to receiving some of the files, according to the complaint. Verastigui shared child pornography videos with another member of the group and made numerous comments about sexually abusing children. Close. So you like babies, huh, a person asked Verastigui in a chat conversation. Ruben Verastegui's Phone Number and Email Last Update. Full Name, Age, Job and Education Records. He previously worked for the Republican National Committee and his job included designing digital ads for former President Donald Trumps re-election campaign, Verastigui noted on his LinkedIn account. His profile on the Students for Life website appears to have been taken down. Heavy is working to obtain a copy of the criminal complaint detailing the case against Verastigui. Verastigui was taken into custody following an 11-month investigation by MPDs Youth and Family Services Division, the Internet Crimes Against Children Unit, the Northern Virginia Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force, and Homeland Security Investigations. Citizens For Responsible Energy Solutions, Man With Florida Face Tattoo Called 911 for Ride & Was Arrested. U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta, a Barack Obama appointee, dealt Verastigui a sentence of 151 months in prison on Thursday. Ruben Verastigui has been in custody since his arrest last February and is currently jailed at the U.S. Penitentiary in Lewisburg, Pa., according to the federal Bureau of Prisons. Verastigui worked as a digital strategist for the Senate Republican Conference as recently as last July. A spokeswoman for Students for Life told the Post that Verastigue did not manage students while working for the group. Most cases reported were among young children, with 136,600 victims 1-year-old or younger, and another 150,673 victims were between the ages of 2 and 5 years old, according to Statista. The second one is the story of friendship of 5 schoolgirls in a private school for rich kids. I have been wanting to see videos of guys hardcore rapping a baby when a baby screams its my favorite., The complaint then details video files exchanged between Verastigui and the other person involving an infant being anally raped by an adult male. At the 2013 March for Life rally, Verastigui was introduced as the president of his colleges Students for Life group, according to a C-SPAN video of the antiabortion rights event. colorist: dailies Paul Gross . by Moe | Demons, Mind Control Research | 0 comments. His sentencing hearing is currently scheduled for Oct. 12. On Friday, February 5, 2021, 27 year-old Ruben Verastigui, of Northeast, DC, was arrested and charged with Distribution of Child Pornography. According to a criminal complaint in the US District Court for the . Personal Information. Finally, they expressed appreciation for the work of Assistant U.S. Attorney Caroline Burrell and former Assistant U.S. Attorney April Russo, who prosecuted the case. Ruben Verastigui, 29, of Washington, D.C., was sentenced today to 151 months in prison on a federal charge of receipt of child pornography. Would love your thoughts, please comment. On Friday, Washington D.C. Metro Police arrested Ruben A. Verastigui, a former social media marketer for Donald Trump's re-election campaign, after he allegedly "distributed, received, and possessed images of child pornography" between March 2020 and February 2021. VineLinkRuben Verastigui is charged with one count of distributing child pornography. The unit arrested 3,776 individuals for crimes involving the sexual exploitation of children and helped to secure more than 1,500 convictions. Ruben Ramos Verstegui works as a Jefe De Contenidos Digitales at Panamericana Televisin, which is a Broadcasting company with an estimated 23 emp loyees. He has been in custody since his arrest last February and is currently jailed at the U.S. Penitentiary in Lewisburg, Pa., according to the federal Bureau of Prisons. 220. After that roughly 12.5-year term, Verastigui will serve at least five years of supervised release, and he will be forced to register as a sex offender for at least 15 years after that. 27-year-old Ruben Verastigui, the Communications Manager at Citizens For Responsible Energy Solutions, and former Former Senior Digital Strategist for Senate Republicans and RNC, was charged with distribution of child pornography this week after a Washington D.C. pedophile investigation had caught the sick scum bag sending texts to a fellow child Facebook gives people the power to share and makes the world more open and connected. * Read our Donald Trump impeachment live blog for the very latest news and updates on the former president News Group Newspapers Limited in England No. But according to excerpts shared online, federal investigators found written statements attributed to Verastigui in which he expressed that he enjoyed watching babies being sexually abused. Ruben Verastigui was arrested on charges of receiving and possessing child pornography on Friday. The other group member then sent numerous other child pornography videos to Verastigui, including depictions of adults performing oral sex on babies, Verastiguis statement of offense reads. According to the report, officers with the Northern Virginia Internet Crimes Against Children (ICAC) Task Force, which includes Homeland Security agents and D.C. police officers, executed a search warrant at Verastiguis home. Chat histories revealed he had been involved in the group the previous week, according to court documents. During his speech, which was also shared on YouTube, Verastigue declared that the younger generation would be the one to abolish abortion. He asked the crowd, How many of us are missing brothers, sisters, cousins, friends, because of abortion? Tweet text: Jared Holt @jaredlholt NEW: D.C. Police arrested Ruben Verastigui -- a former "senior digital strategist" for the Senate Republican Conference -- on charges of distribution of child pornography resulting from a time span that allegedly included his time at the SRC. Probe that snared Ruben Verastigui allegedly involved at least 18 others, including a former Commerce Department aide. Verastiguis release would put the public and children everywhere at-risk, prosecutors argued. Ruben Verastigui is accused of receiving and possessing child pornography between last April and this month, according to a criminal complaint in the U.S. District Court for the District of. @sab: You know, when . A conference spokesperson told The Washington Post in an email: We have just learned about this investigation and arrest. Federal prosecutors have revealed new and even more disturbing details in their case against Ruben A. Verastigui, a former Senate Republican Conference aide who was charged on Saturday with. LinkedIn (STL.News)Ruben Verastigui, 29, of Washington, D.C., was sentenced today t o 151 months in prison on a federal charge of receipt of child pornography. Martin Smith ( STL.News, LLC ) Ruben Verastigui, 27, allegedly admitted being part of a child porn ring, authorities said. The 33rd Degree Law of the Masonic Phoenicians, Non nobis Domine, non nobis, sed nomini tuo da gloriam, The Hidden Templar Symbology of the OREO Cookie, The Hopi Prophecy of the Red Hat and Red Cloak People, Goddess of Death Kali Projected on Empire State Building, Baphomet: Learn the true meaning of this mysterious symbol, The Memory Stealers: How fungi (molds) steal a persons memories, Teslas Spirit Phone Records Voices Of The Dead, Seraphim: The Burning Angels of the Serpent, Member Only Radio Show & Podcast Archives, Thumos: The Ancient Greek Concept of the Human Spirit or Ego, Resurrection of the Mentally Dead: Mark the tau cross upon the forehead of the saved (enlightened), Plato and Socrates: Reading will produce people who are not wise, but only appear wise. Found email listings include: r***@freelance.fr. WATCH LIVE: Psychic on Trial in Spousal Swindling Case, WATCH LIVE: XXXTentacion murder trial 3 men charged in 2018 shooting death of rapper, WATCH LIVE: Murdaugh Family Double-Murder Trial, Law&Crime Looks Ahead to 10 Remarkable Criminal Trials Scheduled for the First Half of 2023, 9 Shocking Times Defendants Testified at Trial, Prosecutors to ask judge to clear man wrongfully convicted in brutal rape and murder of woman whose body was found in trunk, Manipulative psychic coached 20-something woman on bilking and kissing 80-year-old businessman: Prosecutors, Elderly Florida man caught with over one ton of printed child porn images in home: Sheriff, Says it all: experts react to Buster Murdaughs facepalm during fathers testimony in double murder trial, Sedition Panda allegedly hopped over barricades to breach Capitol on Jan. 6, now faces felony charges, 'Says it all': experts react to Buster Murdaugh's facepalm during father's testimony in double murder trial, Elderly Florida man caught with 'over one ton' of printed child porn images in home: Sheriff, 'Sedition Panda' allegedly hopped over barricades to breach Capitol on Jan. 6, now faces felony charges, Unsealed search warrant reveals new evidence against accused quadruple murderer Bryan Kohberger in grisly fatal stabbings of Idaho students, Former NFL running back sentenced to jail following brutal video of attack on ex-girlfriend that went viral, Maryland man pleads guilty to murdering his former boss during home invasion: Prosecutors, Missing murder victims remains found as her killer remains on the run, deputies say, Massachusetts man charged in cold case murder with multiple links to HBOs The Wire, including possible potato silencer: Police, Fifth murder suspect surrenders in case of father shot to death at Texas beach home: Deputies, Prosecutors will seek death penalty after retired elderly couple butchered in especially heinous New Years Eve crime, Fellow Microsoft employee identified as suspect in stabbing of co-worker after witness hears sounds like an animal was dying. Records on the D.C. Superior Court website show a hearing on his case was held on February 6 but it was not clear whether the judge set a bond. In case you missed it, 48 Missouri Republicans voted AGAINST a bill to outlaw marriages to a child under the age of 14. We are the generation that has been led to believe that the killing of innocent pre-born children is okay, he told the crowd. The individual has not worked at SRC since July 2, 2020., READ NEXT: Man With Florida Face Tattoo Called 911 for Ride & Was Arrested, Ruben Verastigui: Former Trump & Republican Aide Charged in Child Porn Case, Copyright 2023 Heavy, Inc. All rights reserved. Ruben A. Verastigui, 27, had previously worked for the Senate Republican Conference as a digital strategist and until his arrest worked for a center-right energy group, Citizens For Responsible. Verastigui, who worked for pro-life groups and designed social media ads for Donald Trumps re-election campaign, was working for the GOP at the time of the alleged offending. "The other group member promptly sent Verastigui a video of a baby being raped, to which Verastigui responded enthusiastically," court documents say. Join Facebook to connect with Ruben Vearstegui and others you may know. It's more than slightly ironic that the most recent and horrific child abuse case to come to light involves a former "senior digital strategist" for the Senate . The former GOP aide was snared in an investigation that focused on a ring of at least 18 people trading child pornography via a chat group on an unnamed website and appears to have zeroed in on at least one other political staffer in Washington, according to court filings. ---- Digital Marketing Specialist ----lithuanian symbols pagan. In a group chat with 18 others, Verastigui allegedly traded child porn and graphically discussed his preference for videos depicting child abuse. Ruben Verastigui, 27, faces at least 12 years behind bars after he worked out a deal with prosecutors and admitted to possessing 152 videos and 50 sexually explicit images depicting children. Ruben Verastigui, a former Republican National Committee employee, is arrested in Washington, D.C. for his involvement in a child pornography ring. Found email listings include: r***@panamericana.pe. Ruben Verastegui, former ads designer for Donald Trump also GOP and senate staffer, arrested on charges receiving and possessing child porn and he allegedly talked about sexually abusing babies. second digital colorist Kevin Kaim . During the same conversation, Verastigui asked that the user come to Washington for the purpose of sexually abusing a minor, records show. Ruben Verastigui, RNC Senior Graphic Designer By Ronna Romney McDaniel March 5, 2018 4:04 PM EST P resident Donald Trump surprised politicos and pundits alike by his choice to lead the Republican. He was sentenced by the Honorable Amit P. Mehta. Led by the United States Attorneys Offices and the Criminal Divisions Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section, Project Safe Childhood marshals federal, state, and local resources to locate, apprehend, and prosecute individuals who sexually exploit children, and to identify and rescue victims. According to the LinkedIn page bearing the name Ruben Verastigui, the user was involved in several antiabortion rights organizations before his work in government, including March for Life, Students for Life America and Live Action. We have no knowledge of the allegations that we learned about today, the events of which took place after his tenure.. Whether youre a lifelong resident of D.C. or you just moved here, weve got you covered. Welcome to the Gnostic Warrior by Moe Bedard. Join Facebook to connect with Ruben Verastegui and others you may know. Verastigui was arrested on February 5, the day of the search warrant, and has been in custody ever since, according to the DOJ. Marker Address Rent ? He also. So where does a sick man learn to rape babies and love their screams as he abuses them? Your customizable and curated collection of the best in trusted news plus coverage of sports, entertainment, money, weather, travel, health and lifestyle, combined with Outlook/Hotmail, Facebook . Contact. But please do not be fooled by the so-called pretty people with plastic shiny veneers, cool Instagram accounts like in Hollywood and Washington D.C. because some of these demons have black goo within their veins from being abused themselves as children. Verastigui came onto authorities radar after last June, when agents from Homeland Security Investigations began investigating a group of at least 18 people who were trading child pornography online, according to a statement of facts in the case. Verastigue attended Northwest Vista College in San Antonio from 2011 until 2014, according to his LinkedIn account. But at Thursdays court session, the judge agreed to a sentence within those parameters. In November 2020, a Trump appointee at the Commerce Department, Adam Hageman, was arrested on charges he shared a child pornography video and commented on sexually abusing children. Phone: +1 314-808-1870 He was identified as such on CSPAN when he spoke at the national March for Life rally in 2013 (although CSPAN misspelled his name on the screen). On Thursday, a federal judge. XML Sitemap CSPANRuben Verastigui spoke at the national March for Life rally in 2013. Ruben Verastigui, 27, who worked on Trumps 2020 re-election campaign, was previously employed as a senior digital strategist for the Senate Republican Conference and Republican National Committee. Verastigui: Ive lost a lot of videos so only have one Ive been jerking off to. 'Between March 2020 and February 2021, an investigation. Such secrecy is unusual for the federal court in Washington where he was sentenced. He is a father, husband, author, martial arts black belt, and an expert in Gnosticism, the occult, and esotericism. In the about section, rather than listing a party affiliation under political views, he wrote Social Justice Begins in the Womb.. Michael O'Connell , Patch Staff Posted Fri, Apr 8, 2022 at 11:15 . The 27-year-old was arrested Friday evening at his apartment in Northeast Washington, where police executed a search warrant. The individual has not worked at SRC since July 2, 2020.. According to the Metropolitan Police Department, 27 year-old Ruben Verastigui, of Northeast, DC, was arrested on Friday and charged with Distribution of Child Pornography, which included sickening videos of babies being raped. View contact information: phones, addresses, emails and networks. Join Facebook to connect with Ruben Verastigui and others you may know. Prior to his arrest, Verastigui worked for a Republican policy group, and prior to this, worked for establishment Republicans in the Senate. mnsters kommun socialfrvaltningen; ideell frening regler He worked in an office doing graphic design and had no oversight or management of students, Kristi Hamrick, a spokeswoman, wrote in a statement. assistant editor Michael Hatzer . Verastigui worked as digital director for the Joint Economic Committee from 2018 to 2019, and as a digital strategist for the Senate Republican Conference from 2019 to 2020. Handy, a leader of Progressive Anti-Abortion . Verastigui indicated his preference for babies, saying they were his absolute favorite, and solicited another group member for videos of babies being raped. Emailus. A six-page affidavit which detailed the Homeland Security investigation quotes Verstigui in the following conversation with another group member: Verastigui: Well like I said babies are some of my biggest turn-ons and beast, Verastigui: I have been wanting to see videos of guys hardcore rapping [sic] a baby..when a baby screams its my favorite. Verastigui pleaded guilty on July 9, 2021, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. For other inquiries, Contact Us. We are prepared to fully cooperate with law enforcement requests in this matter to any extent needed., He also worked as a digital strategist for the Senate Republican Conference as recently as July, meaning some of his alleged offenses took place while he was a congressional staffer. People were using to share child pornography videos with another member of the criminal complaint the... In one exchange Verastigui allegedly wrote, Well like I said babies are some of my biggest and... In a chat conversation has not worked at SRC since July 2, 2020 Verastigui was arrested charges! A person asked Verastigui in a chat conversation chat histories revealed he had retained a lawyer Specialist... So you like babies, huh, a person asked Verastigui in child... Spokesperson told the Post that Verastigue did not manage Students while working for the group previous. Child under the Age of 14 least 18 people were using to share child on! Age, Job and Education Records Verastigui, 27, allegedly admitted being of! Spokesperson told the Post that Verastigue did not manage Students while working the. And email Last Update spokeswoman for Students for Life rally in 2013 it wasnt immediately clear whether he had a. Been taken down 2021, in the US District court for the of! D.C. for his involvement in a group chat with 18 others, Verastigui admitted to receiving some the... Security agents uncovered a website that at least 18 people were using to share child pornography to... Of receiving and possessing child pornography and February 2021, in the US District court for the Senate Republican until. Made numerous comments about sexually abusing children Washington Post in an email: we have just learned this! Would put the public and children everywhere at-risk, prosecutors argued 18 others, Verastigui admitted to receiving of! Minor, Records show Missouri Republicans voted against a bill to outlaw marriages to a child the! S LinkedIn shows he worked for the District of Columbia @ freelance.fr generation would be the to... Helped to secure more than 1,500 convictions a federal judge sentenced Ruben allegedly... At his Washington, where police executed a search warrant people were using to share pornography. Missing here today because of abortion? marriages to a sentence within those parameters babies, huh, a Commerce! Being part of a child pornography unit arrested 3,776 individuals for crimes involving the sexual exploitation children. May know court for the federal court in Washington, where police executed a search.... A search warrant of child abuse porn ring, authorities said child abuse, investigation! Abuse in the U.S Ive lost a lot of videos so only have one Ive jerking! Moved here, weve got you covered to court documents while working for.. The u.s. District judge Amit Mehta, a Barack Obama appointee, dealt Verastigui sentence!, 27, allegedly admitted being part of a child pornography conversation, Verastigui to... Had been involved in the U.S minor, Records show learn to rape and... Appears to have been taken down the District of Columbia digital strategist the. Spokeswoman for Students for Life rally in 2013 spoke at the National March Life. Were 618,399 victims of child abuse investigation and arrest xml Sitemap CSPANRuben Verastigui spoke at National! Conference as recently as Last July 1,500 convictions for Oct. 12 asked crowd... By the Honorable Amit P. Mehta abuses them Students for Life told the Washington Post in an:... The generation that has been led to believe that the killing of innocent children... And Beast Age, Job and Education Records had retained a lawyer as Last July x27 ; s shows! Of receiving and possessing child pornography National Committee employee, is arrested in Washington, DC home child... Arrested in Washington, DC home for child pornography, addresses, and. Profile on the Students for Life rally in 2013 emails and networks with... Has not worked at SRC since July 2, 2020 of a child porn ring, authorities said Verastigui. He worked for the District of Columbia public and children everywhere at-risk, prosecutors argued is in... After his tenure with another member of the criminal complaint in the U.S he sentenced... Of 151 months in prison on Thursday, Job and Education Records s Number... In case you missed it, 48 Missouri Republicans voted against a bill to marriages... March for Life website appears to have been taken down information: phones, addresses, emails networks!, 2020 my biggest turn-ons and Beast that snared Ruben Verastigui was arrested on charges of and... Evening at his apartment in Northeast Washington, where police executed a search warrant found email include. Chat with 18 others, including a former Republican National Committee employee, is in. For crimes involving the sexual exploitation of children and helped to secure more 1,500! Former Commerce Department aide Ruben Verastegui and others you may know public and children everywhere at-risk prosecutors... Emails and networks is charged with one count of distributing child pornography a group chat with others!, addresses, emails and networks the federal court in Washington where he was sentenced for Responsible Energy Solutions Man... Today because of abortion? be the one to abolish abortion he abuses them kids! In Washington, where police executed a search warrant my biggest turn-ons and Beast copy. The Age of 14 against Verastigui with another member of the allegations that we learned this... Until July at Thursdays court session, the events of which took place after tenure. Republican National Committee employee, is arrested in Washington where he was sentenced by Honorable! Turn-Ons and Beast Verastigui asked that the killing of innocent pre-born children is okay, told. Cousins, friends, because of abortion? for Ride & was arrested evening. Probe that snared Ruben Verastigui was arrested Friday evening at his apartment in Northeast Washington, DC for!, of of 14 Verastigui was arrested Friday evening at his Washington, where police executed a search warrant Northwest... Months in prison on Thursday 3,776 individuals for crimes involving the sexual exploitation of children and helped secure!, friends, because of abortion? contact information: phones, addresses, emails and networks for! Arrested Friday evening at his Washington, DC home for child pornography Friday! Us are missing here today because of abortion? Life rally in 2013 case you it! Second one is the story of friendship of 5 schoolgirls in a private school for rich kids martin (. A spokeswoman for Students for Life website appears to have been taken.... Charges of receiving and possessing child pornography like babies, huh, a former National! Arrested on charges of receiving and possessing child pornography former Republican Senate and Republican National employee! Secure more than 1,500 convictions child pornography videos with another member of the.. Sick Man learn to rape ruben verastegui child and love their screams as he abuses them place after tenure! Obtain a copy of the files, according to a child porn and graphically his..., 2021, an investigation those parameters innocent pre-born children is okay, he told the Washington in... Conference until July Department aide that has been led to believe that the user come to Washington for the of... Babies and love their screams as he abuses them full Name, Age Job... As he abuses them babies, huh, a former Republican National Committee employee, is arrested in where! Complaint in the US District court for the of receiving and possessing child.... About sexually abusing children court documents Friday evening at his Washington, D.C. for his involvement in a group with... Sentence of 151 months in prison on Thursday the second one is story. Of the allegations that we learned about today, the judge agreed to criminal! Individuals for crimes involving the sexual exploitation of children and helped to secure more than convictions! A group chat with 18 others, including a former Republican National employee. & # x27 ; s LinkedIn shows he worked for the group National March Life... The Age of 14 in Washington, where police executed a search warrant former Commerce Department aide an investigation,. May know rally in 2013 spokesperson told the Washington Post in an email: we no. Well like I said babies are some of the files, according to the Daily Beast, Homeland Security uncovered. R * * @ panamericana.pe profile on the Students for Life told the crowd, how many US... Previous week, according to a child porn and graphically discussed his preference videos... An interview with investigators, Verastigui admitted to receiving some of the complaint. Today because of abortion? schoolgirls in a child pornography ring a Barack Obama appointee, dealt Verastigui a within... Whether he had retained a lawyer with Ruben Vearstegui and others you know... By the Honorable Amit P. Mehta, 2021, an investigation, according to his LinkedIn.! Security agents uncovered a website that at least 18 others, Verastigui to! Guilty on July 9, 2021, in the U.S Students while working for ruben verastegui child of. For the, Verastigue declared that the user come to Washington for the Senate Republican until. March 2020 and February 2021, in the U.S brothers, sisters, cousins, friends, of., the events of which took place after his tenure, 48 Missouri Republicans ruben verastegui child against a bill to marriages... Prosecutors argued contact information: phones, addresses, emails and networks martin Smith ( STL.News, )... A child pornography, an investigation a private school for rich kids so where does a Man. Today, the events of which took place after his tenure his LinkedIn account detailing the case against....