h, The immigration judges who led training in 2020 had, on average, much higher deportation rates than those in 2016, before Trump took office. In a complaint filed with EOIR last year, a coalition of 17 law firms, community organizations and the San Francisco public defender representing dozens of clients singled out Judge Nicholas Ford, a former state criminal court judge hired in 2019. Interns wanted: Get paid to help ensure that every voter has unbiased election information. (Checks hands.) Decisions. As of Friday, associate circuit Judge Scott Lipke was the only candidate to file for the position. Last Friday, Biden signed an executive order unwinding many of Trumps civil service-related actions, which the new president said had undermined the foundations of the civil service and its merit system principles.. width: 43%; color: white; Make hay while the sun shines. The 32nd Judicial Circuit includes Bollinger, Cape Girardeau, and Perry Counties. % Congratulations to Gardner and Thomsen on these new roles. font-size: 1.2em; | There are times for swift, decisive governmental action. I dont think he denies asylum cases because he enjoys denying nor because he is evil, close minded, or exclusionary, said Antonini. Last October, Trump issued an executive order that could have led to tens of thousands of government positions being converted from civil service positions to ones where employees can be fired without cause. Please, Website of the Superior Court of Nevada County, Office of the Governor, Press Release: "Gov. That history may have left the new administration sensitive about any perception that it is short-circuiting the laws and rules. The likelihood hes going to be able to tackle complicated issues with an oral decision is nil, one staffer wrote. background-color: white; r(0IM.,c69"2[*Q;Rh_h/,*5Awd%HfD]b]E+9Mi, rAQ+c&Huj+V In-classroom training is followed by on-the-job training that includes a structured mentorship program, EOIR said. The Trump administration issued a series of precedent-setting decisions and rules that made asylum cases more difficult to win. color: white; Immigration Court. .top_disclaimer { SAS Output. margin-top: 1px; margin-bottom:0px; Superior Court of Nevada County California Seat 3, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, .infobox { One immigration advocate said that Biden transition personnel at the Department of Homeland Security seemed more urgently focused on immigration issues, while those issues appeared to be put on the back burner by those planning for the Justice Department. Now 37-year-old entrepreneur business owner Vivek Ramaswamy has entered the race as the newest Republican candidate. Scott E. Thomsen (Ret.) If he is allowed to stay in office, the many steps he has taken to steamroll cases through the courts for removal orders will continue apace. Support our mission. Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions in Immigration Courts. Applicants to these civil service positions are interviewed by panels of senior judges on the court as well as DOJ officials. Among the judges they observed was Earle Wilson, who had the highest asylum denial rate in Georgia and the sixth highest in the nation at 98 percent between fiscal years 2013 and 2018. margin-bottom: 0; .widget-row.Democratic { font-weight: bold; Detailed law firm profiles have information like the firm's area of law, office location, office hours, and payment options. In their own court cases, the Trump-administration training judges ordered immigrants deported 75% of the time, while trainers in 2016 had a deportation rate of 58%. McHenry made major strides towards replacing the courts archaic paper-based filing system with a computerized one, hired a record number of new immigration judges and sharply increased the number of cases closed out every year at least before Covid-19 hit. Most of the people that are coming unlawfully between ports of entry on the southwest border are not eligible for any recognized form of asylum, Miller said in an interview. For more than 115 years, the Southeast Missourian has written the first draft of local history.

float:right; He was elected in 2014 following the retirement of Judge William Syler. The six-member 32nd Judicial Circuit Court will be down two members for some period of time. Many immigration judges and immigration lawyers have urged that the immigration courts be moved outside of the Justice Department to give them greater independence. I was sort of surprised when I got the appointment to the New York City Immigration Court.. } While we may not always have liked his answers, he always provided those answers, McKinney said. 	width: 250px; He was appointed by former governor Arnold Schwarzenegger in December 2010 to succeed C. Anders Holmer. John Grimm, son to Stanley Grimm and a local attorney himself, told the Southeast Missourian diversity of all types is important on the Court of Appeals, which includes geographic diversity. Scott Thomsen, an associate judge in Bollinger County for the 32nd Judicial Circuit, was recently selected as a federal immigration judge in New York City. Sign up for free updates. A policy requiring a prosecutor to charge every case referred for prosecution.without regard for individual circumstances is inconsistent with our principles, Wilkinson wrote. from the University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law.[1]. Office For Immigration Review 26 Federal Plz # 12 New York, NY, 10278-0004 Scott E. Thomsen New York, NY, 10278 View 2 other locations Review Scott Cost We have not found any cost information for this lawyer Contact for Details Resume Education Brigham Young University - J. Reuben Clark Law School N/A Attorney endorsements Received (0) Given (0) His last day with the circuit court is March 14. Find and Rate Your Immigration Judge Search "To hear courteously, to answer wisely, to consider soberly, and to decide impartially." The model of a good judge has not changed over the past 2500 years since Socrates uttered these words. Thomsen and his wife, Joanna, have six children. [3] Elections 2014 See also: Missouri judicial elections, 2014 From October 2018 to August 2019, he served as an Immigration Judge at the LaSalle Immigration Court. We wish them well.  	padding-left: 10px; In their own court cases, the Trump-administration. Attorney General William P. Barr appointed Scott E. Thomsen as an immigration judge in March 2020. } Gardner, who is set to be sworn in March 11, said most oral arguments will be heard in St. Louis. 	width: 150px; Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions in Immigration Courts. 	word-wrap: break-word; stream 	display: inline-block; 	background-color: #f9f9f9; d[r6SApSF\F\l The airport registered 8,132 enplanements in 2022, which surpassed the 8,000 enplanements benchmark to receive $600,000 from the federal government. 	color: black; 	color: white; I saw that list.and I was just shocked, said Jeremy McKinney, an immigration lawyer in Greensboro, N.C., prior to Wednesdays announcement. He is registered decline-to-state. (703) 544-0050. In September, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) opened an investigation into alleged politicization and mismanagement of immigration courts after 10 Democratic senators accused the attorney general of subverting the hiring process to promote partisan judges and to increase political influence, according to an announcement from the senators at the time. .widget-value { She said the agency continually evaluates its processes and procedures to ensure that immigration cases are adjudicated fairly, impartially and expeditiously..  0|{,Gh J3
 So I think its a great deal for the court, Lewis said. In 2008, an inspector generals probe found DOJ officials in the George W. Bush administration violated federal law by considering candidates political and ideological affiliations. The personnel change comes after complaints from immigration advocates who were troubled to see McHenrys name on the agency-wide list the Justice Department released last Thursday of those holding top posts on an acting or continuing basis for the first weeks of the Biden presidency. There is presently a great deal of discussion about the fact that the United States has reached the national debt limit set by Congress. New hires have three weeks of training, which consists of lessons in topics ranging from determining immigrants credibility to handling juvenile and domestic violence cases to fraud and abuse prevention, according to training documents reviewed by Reuters. 	vertical-align: top; However, working together in a collaborative way is almost always the best On Tuesday we will celebrate Valentine's Day, a holiday dedicated to the celebration of love and marriage. Judge Leon Francis, a former military judge, was hired in 2018. Gardner and Thomsen have met both of those qualifications. Ballotpedia features 395,443 encyclopedic articles written and curated by our professional staff of editors, writers, and researchers. It also excluded cases in which the immigrant waived the right to a hearing and those terminated without a decision or closed at the request of a prosecutor. Thomsen ran for re-election to the 32nd Judicial Circuit Court.Primary: He ran unopposed in the Republicanprimary on August 5, 2014.General: He was unopposed in the general election on November 4, 2014. Ashburn, VA Immigration Attorney. For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/. 	margin: auto; Choose from a broad listing of topics suited for law firms, corporate legal departments, and government entities. How encouraging it is to know that all people are not a mistake but loved by our great Sunday is the big day for professional football fans. Lewis called Thomsen a friend and good, solid person.. But the timing is unclear, particularly for Gardners seat since he was up for reelection this year. Scott Thomsen, an associate judge for Missouri's 32nd Judicial Circuit Court, has been appointed by U.S. Attorney General William Barr to serve as a federal judge with the U.S.. Its been a great honor to serve as a circuit judge for the last five years, but I think the best contribution I can make to public service would be as an appellate judge, he said. "The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) announces the investiture of 46 immigration judges, including three assistant chief immigration judges. 	padding-left: 10px; It also accounted for the immigrants nationality and other details about the case and judge. November 7, 2006 - Re-elected It is always nice to hear ambitious young people also add Donald Trump and a lot of cameras flew into East Palestine, Ohio, on Wednesday. hTAk@27dMH)"hbl/kvb&0"EY ,:7Qidds-Aap1G:S='BKmE^1!~Sqp   Immigration Court. Thomsen was also involved with the Bollinger County Chamber of Commerce, the Bollinger County Optimist Club, and The General Society of Mayflower Descendants. endstream
endobj
631 0 obj
<>stream
 0J^T3w_dr(LzSKDMIig
{uVsrf$\a3JMN'uF/lxS5$C5Q{27-;K	!J/D7AGUn.   Judge Thomsen earned a Bachelor of Science in 1988 and a Juris Doctor in 1991 from Brigham Young University. 	width: 43%; EOIRs Mattingly said the agency has maintained a robust training plan for all judges; she did not address Reuters specific findings on training.  :t>?m`^;^6Q #4gUs(:+*[m8:33pP8mnw!ZBjj (b&n\rxs&Vx5 Several new judges without previous experience in immigration have come under criticism from immigration attorneys, colleagues and others. Browse more than one million listings, covering everything from DUI to divorce to reckless driving. Immigration judges and appellate judges are selected through an open and competitive process, free of political influence, she said. Hiring wasnt the only thing that changed under Trump. Under U.S. law, immigrants are eligible for asylum only if they can prove they were being persecuted in their home countries on the basis of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group or their political opinions. Note: Special discounts available to new subscribers only. But after the BIA closed his case, the government filed new immigration charges against him, also stemming from his prior gang affiliation. He filled the vacancy created by the retirement of the Hon. Gardner said he decided while in law school he would commit his career to public service as a judge. There is a law exam midway through to determine judges comprehension of the material.  One signatory was then-Senator Kamala Harris, now Bidens vice president. .widget-row.value-only.black { Climate-conscious clause are becoming more common in supply . } Click here to contact our editorial staff, and click here to report an error. I think he believes his job is to follow precedent as defined by the training he has received.. in accounting from Brigham Young University in 1988. 	display: inline-block; If you have an account, follow this link to log in. Presiding circuit Judge Ben Lewis told the Southeast Missourian on Friday senior judges Gary Kamp and William Syler will assist with cases while the court is down a third of its judges. The 2024 presidential race gets more exciting each day. As the top executive branch official overseeing the immigration courts, McHenry spearheaded a series of policy initiatives that rankled immigration advocates, including efforts to narrow asylum. Another official involved in hiring, who declined to be named, shared this observation. .infobox p { .top_disclaimer { Ford did not respond to a request for comment. The Trump administration revised hiring for immigration judges to allow temporary appointments before background investigations were completed and gave the EOIR director more control over the process. Two local judges have been tapped for roles at the state and federal levels. } 630 0 obj
<>stream
 Thomsen was re-elected in 2012. [2], Thomsen received his undergraduate degree from Menlo College and his J.D. } 	background-color: #f9f9f9; } Lewis said Gardner is bright, hard working and has a lot of common sense. He added he is happy to see the governor appoint someone to the Court of Appeals who has been a trial judge in outstate Missouri. Asst. Unlike other federal courts, the immigration courts operate within the Executive Branch under authority delegated by the attorney general. Thomsen retired in 2020 after being selected to serve as an immigration judge on the Immigration Court with the Executive Office for Immigration Review under the Department of Justice in New York City. McHenry was named as acting chief of EOIR in May 2017 and was given the permanent director title the following January. The administration filled two-thirds of the immigration courts 520 lifetime positions with judges who, as a whole, have disproportionately ordered deportation, according to a Reuters analysis of more than 800,000 immigration cases decided over the past 20 years. .widget-row { C. Anders Holmer (Ret.). 	background-color: grey;  immigration judge grants denials tabaddor, a. ashley 13 41 tadal, mirlande 5 24 taylor, bruce a. The House Select Committee on the Strategic Competition Between the United States and the Chinese Communist Party held its first hearing this week. He has always been consistent when meeting with us to answer our questions. Other times, though, call for officials to be deliberate, thoughtful, cautious. Michael Gardner, a circuit judge on the 32nd Judicial Circuit of Cape Girardeau, Perry and Bollinger counties, was appointed by Gov. As an immigration judge, Scott Thomsen will hear and determine the immigration status of non-citizens and their families and ascertain asylum claims. }x2;=^;9Inb1~3yX*.   Keller, the former chief immigration judge, recalled a 2017 conversation about a new judge - a former ICE prosecutor - who McHenry wanted to start hearing cases immediately.   Missouri Municipal Courts, Courts in Missouri  Missouri judicial elections  Judicial selection in Missouri. He was appointed by former governor Arnold Schwarzenegger in December 2010 to succeed C. Anders Holmer. B. Scott Thomsen is a judge for the Nevada County Superior Court in California. Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. During that . The Federal Aviation Strike while the iron is hot. From 1995 to 2020, he served as the associate circuit judge for nd Bollinger County, Missouri. After a thorough application process, Attorney General William P. Barr appointed Brandon M. Bolling, Jonathan W. Hitesman, Daren K. Margolin, Sherron Ashworth, John Cody Barnes, J. Thomas Bartleson, Judith F. Bonilla, Jeremy J. Butler, Andrew M. Calvelli, Lorianne M. Campanella, Charissa S. Dvorak, David W. Evans, Ryan A. Fisher, David A. Fraiden, Amber D. George, Robert J. Gundlach, Lakshmi Srinivasan Herman, Denise A. Hinds Roach, Amanda R. Jeannopoulos, Arkesia S. Jenkins, Allan F. John-Baptiste, Colin P. Johnson, Michael P. Klosowsky, Andrea Koppenhofer, Carolyn L. Krasinski, Edward F. Lee, Michael W. Lloyd, Luis A. Maldonado, Steven Marcus, John W. McPhail, Leila A. Mullican, Matthew J. OBrien, Kristin Piepmeier, Daniel J. Redwood, Dara F. Reid, David V. Rhoden, Jose A. Rivera-Ortiz, David A. Russo, Michael A. Schnitzer, Joseph C. Scott, Elvin R. Talavera-Peraza, Kenley J. Thompson, Scott E. Thomsen, Michael A. Tripi, Curtis G. White, and David White to their new positions. LexisNexis CLE On-Demand features premium content from partners like American Law Institute Continuing Legal Education and Pozner & Dodd. .infobox p { OZFFz$?Na35@P(
XokXd\X,wr/C$KR)ziovw9Y6^rM!]l].lwO~g  L#
 Biography. They said Ford routinely discounts or minimizes reports of mistreatment or torture, and repeatedly misapplies the legal standards for asylum.. 	color: white; Immigration court decisions can be appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) within EOIR, and subsequently to the United States courts of appeals. Given the attention to Wilkinsons minor role in that widely-denounced policy, it was notable that when the Justice Department formally jettisoned part of that policy this week, the announcement came in a memo from Wilkinson. Sitting immigration judges are not permitted to speak to the media. 	text-align: center; .widget-row.Independent, .widget-row.Nonpartisan, .widget-row.Constitution { } Judicial Branch, Southeast Missourian: Carolina Antonini, an attorney who has defended immigrants in front of Judge John Gillies, a 2018 hire who has a deportation rate of 92%, said she thinks he acts in good faith even though she disagrees with his decisions. border:1px solid #FFB81F; } width: 250px; The problem was with some of the other judges that seemed to not be able to manage their dockets, or, in many cases, rendered rulings that were not consistent with the law.. Detailed law firm profiles have information like the firm's area of law, office location, office hours, and payment options. McHenry, formerly a deputy to a top Justice Department official, played a more active role in the hiring of judges than his predecessors, said MaryBeth Keller, a former chief immigration judge who served under McHenry and was deeply involved in hiring until she resigned in 2019. Posting a comment requires a subscription. Judge Chowdhury. That day, Romero was afraid. lS@"i! Hes done everything that you can do in that position out there in Bollinger County, and hes done a great job, he said. 	font-size: .9em; Our core values have remained firm: truth, service, quality, integrity and community. }  Ballotpedia does not currently cover this office or maintain this page.  	vertical-align: top;  	margin: auto; He said the appellate court can be a lonely place because judges do not deal with the public and mainly spend time reading briefs. 	font-weight: bold; 2 38 thompson, donald w., jr. 271 98 tijerina, eric j. For each Premium Issue, your account balance will be charged an additional fee in the billing period when the section publishes.  In one case outlined in the complaint, lawyers alleged that Ford referred to what their client, a woman from El Salvador, described as daily beatings by her father as a childhood in which she was spanked by her dad. The alleged domestic abuse was one of several factors she said led her to flee her country. I had applied for the position and there were some positions available at the time in various parts of the country, he told Banner Press editor Mary Layton. Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. I encourage our leaders to fund city needs We understand each community has its own identity, its own opportunities and its own challenges. After the primary election, Thomsen was automatically re-elected. 	color: white; In 2018, more than a dozen liberal lawyers sent a letter complaining that Trump appointees were mistreating members of the senior executive service by reassigning them as retaliation and potentially in violation of civil service protections. This will result in shortening the length of your billing period. His removal is imperative to the new administration being able to implement its vision of make courts fairer and more efficient.. } } 	display: inline-block; Reuters spoke with eight other former immigration judges, five of whom served under Trump, who generally echoed her view. In a February 2020 letter to the attorney general, the senators cited concerns raised by the immigration judges union, former judges and the American Bar Association.  @8=uu@hZ7cg'&8~:ytG79`V8[O8q:|O\8~B#=,ir1?nAK~;~{ZS
/*p	]b.2Te)]?r|]/IL%FrkXbh#I*1.-R$&6YG,5IbB6%:oi'VMJ,U# UIb.hV
h7VIbz$U^T
PeYZe,%6,UX$U 6VIb"AS#HBJ,UVD$%&dVEXbBfM[Y;,U|S1Xb"Xb"J,Ui[Y*ILU$!dTD Its important to have judges at all levels of the judiciary with good legal minds and a heart for public service. Simpson, Scott Cervantes, Rene San Francisco 100 Montgomery Street, Suite 800 San Francisco, CA 94104 415-705-4415 San Francisco (Detained) 630 Sansome Street, 4th Floor, . endstream
endobj
635 0 obj
<>stream
 The music was simple. Biden has promised to dramatically expand the courts by doubling the number of immigration judges and other staff. Thats a worthwhile effort, said Stephen Legomsky, a former chief counsel of the U.S. Click here to contact us for media inquiries, and please donate here to support our continued expansion. endstream
endobj
634 0 obj
<>stream
 And the way attorneys handle things is different in Hannibal and Cape Girardeau and Perryville compared to the way they do things in St. Louis and St. Louis County.. Hes (Gardner) young, and hell have a lot of years hell be able to serve in that position. 	background-color: #f9d334; There is a certain amount of community pride. A GAO spokesman said its current investigation is just getting underway.. Stephen Miller, the key architect of Trumps immigration agenda, told Reuters that the administration had aimed to hire more immigration judges as part of an effort to create more integrity in the asylum process and quickly resolve what he termed meritless claims to cut down on a massive backlog. Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions in Immigration Courts FY 2017-2022 Published Oct 9, 2022 Denial Rate Tables for Prior Periods TRAC is a nonpartisan, nonprofit data research center affiliated with the Newhouse School of Public Communications and the Whitman School of Management, both at Syracuse University. .widget-img { .infobox { Apply today! Court Address Immigration Judges Court Administrator Otero 26 McGregor Range Rd., Door #1 Chaparral, NM 88081 575-824-8900 Fernandez, Lorely Ramirez French, Kathy Fordham University School of Law and New . From 1990 to 1996, he was a general practitioner and handled a wide variety of civil litigation.