Tiger has overcome several challenges over its two decades, including losses stemming from the 2008 financial crisis. Then Coleman added: Weve answered skeptical questions about China for each of the past 17 years. That way, a big winner in the venture-capital portfolio could become a big winner in the hedge-fund portfolio. Chinese startups that succeed from now on will be those that can play by Chinas rules and still perform financially, said Nazar Yasin, a former Tiger executive who founded VC firm Rise Capital. Privacy Policy and Republicans are making their 2024 candidates promise to support eventual nominee. February 22, 2023. Like many others interviewed for this article, he requested anonymity because he feared repercussions from the firm. He married Stephanie Ercklentz (who appeared to her later regret in Jamie Johnsons 2003 BORN RICH) in the celebrated Bethesda-by-the Sea Church. Tiger Globals Chase Coleman, Scott Shleifer and John Curtius. This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. (These hedge-fund firms have also followed Tiger Global into investing in venture capital. His fund sank 13% in January after being caught off-guard by an unexpected drop in bond yields. Griffin, 54,made$4.1 billion last year alone. 24 Aug, 2021, 06.00 AM IST Infra.Market gets funding at $2.5-billion valuation, eyes acquisitions Theyll say that crossovers that is, hedge funds that got into venture capital are drastically overpricing rounds, not doing enough diligence on their investments, or are in some other way breaking the spoken & unspoken rules of venture, Everett Randle, a partner at San Franciscobased venture capital firm Founders Fund, wrote on his blog last year in the midst of Tigers most aggressive financing spree. The deal has now been agreed to, all the lawsuits back and forth have been dropped, and it seems in spite of additional yelling and complaining by some, particularly town councilman Jeffrey Bragman, its done. Shailendra Singh: Surge . It is clear that Shleifer is taking bolder bets compared to Fixel, the original bull of the Indian consumer internet market. Image Credits: Tiger Global. Scott Shleifer, co-founder of Tiger Global Managements private-equity unit, set a Palm Beach record yesterday with his purchase of a nine-bedroom, 21,000-square-foot manse for $132 million. Coleman owns at least 75% of the firm, a filing shows. With its aggressive style, Tiger helped drive up valuations overall for such companies, boosting the rise of the so-called unicorns privately owned start-ups worth more than $1 billion. Well-known Tiger investments such as Peloton, Roblox, Uber, Robinhood, Warby Parker, and Carvana have been among the biggest losers in U.S. markets in some cases down more than 90 percent. In it, Coleman told Mallaby that when he launched Tiger Global, he felt daunted by the idea of hiring investment professionals older than him. Scott Shleifer, who graduated from Beaverton High, is now a successful financial investor. The fact Sam never returned home makes Dr. Ben Song's decision to jump even more harrowing, so one could argue Scott Bakula's lack of involvement has added more drama to the revival. But my guess is there are a lot of debates going on in their boardrooms about how aggressively to invest going forward. more: Soross Fitzpatrick Says Firm Not Putting Money Into China. During a company gathering in Miami in early 2020, some employees went to a popular Miami nightclub called E11even. Its long-only fund has fallen even more some 60 percent this year. Reach out to reporters Rebecca Ungarino at (646) 768-4711 and rungarino@insider.com and Dakin Campbell at (917) 408-3732 and dcampbell@insider.com. Shleifer is known to verbally attack people in meetings, and tell junior employees that their ideas are stupid, according to the people who spoke to Insider. It was bank balance sheets. The oceanfront home sits on property formerly owned by Donald Trump, was sold fully-furnished, and features an outdoor movie theater. A true American blue blood, he is a descendent of Peter Stuyvesant, the last Dutch governor of New York. Its partners do not talk to the media, nor do they speak at industry conferences. She explains the press to the president, preaches Twitter-is-not-real-life, and keeps the West Wing from leaking. We've received your submission. So this big risk that you would have a great country that would gain share in GDP, but there wouldnt just be excess profit pools that could have a sustainable competitive advantage, we think the odds of that has fallen off a cliff., He argued that the historical low returns in India allowed the country to enter the downturn in a better position than the U.S. You did not have much excess capital in India as there were in few other places.. India has attracted over $75 billion in investment from tech giants such as Google, Meta, Walmart, Microsoft and Amazon and investors including Sequoia, Tiger Global, Accel and Lightspeed over the past decade. The state has a near-total abortion ban, and now activists and GOP officials are fighting an exemption for physician-defined medical emergencies. The 25-year-old analyst, who had worked at Robertsons storied Tiger Management and was a close friend of his sons, seemed shy and insecure. And so at some point, it stopped working., Tiger Global had created a symbiotic relationship between its hedge-fund holdings and its venture-capital investments. And a linguist named Emily M. Bender is very worried what will happen when we forget this. The philosophical debate behind the lab-leak question. In most cases, youre not allowed to do this, says Michael Ewens, a finance professor at the California Institute of Technology who studies entrepreneurship, referring to provisions in contracts between VC fund managers and their investors. In 2022, our portfolio of investments in India performed far closer to budget from the beginning of the year compared to our companies in any other geography.. WebScott Shleifer, managing director of Tiger Global Management LLC, left, and wife Elena Shleifer, stand for a photograph during the UJA-Federation of New York Wall Street Dinner in New York, U.S., on Wednesday, Dec. 14, 2011. Based in New York City, Tiger Global was never part of the Silicon Valley culture of seeking out visionary founders and holding the hands of entrepreneurs. February 22, 2023. The land was once part of a 6.2-acre estate that housed Maison de LAmitie, or House of Friendship. The several buildings on this property were historic, the location faced the sunset over water, and it was just a wonderful thing to go down there for a lobster roll and fries and a nice beer. Scott Shleifer December 12, 2019 Share: FacebookTweetLinkedIn Scott Shleifer Age:37 Founder and Managing Director of Tiger Global Managements private equity unit. For Tiger Global, whose strategy seems innately tied to the tech bubble, what can they say? Most of the large portfolio managers all know each other. To contact the authors of this story:
Their losses look to be the biggest in the history of hedge funds, says one hedge-fund manager, ticking off other notable contenders for that unfortunate title. Tiger has emerged as a brash disruptor in the clubby VC world, rattling rival bidders with its aggressive approach and uncommon speed. Shleifer joined in 2002 as an early hire at Tiger and co-founded its private-equity investing arm. Tiger is fundraising for its latest fund, Private Investment Partners 16, which has a $6 billion target. In true Tiger Global tradition, the transaction was completed in record time. He cofounded Tiger Global Management's private investment arm in 2003. As of September 2022, his net worth was estimated at US$3.5 billion. In a buoyant market, the stocks typically took off, as fellow Tiger cubs as well as other hedge funds bought into what became a growth-stock bubble. Haidar, a trader who started his hedge fund more than 25 years ago, reflects a resurgence in the hedge fund worlds old guard after being outpaced at times in recent years by more tech-focused investors like Chase Coleman and his fellow Tiger Cubs. Despite Griffins haul, the $13.8 billion collected by the 15 top-earning managers was the lowest annual total since 2019. Harry is moving on. Now he is letting the world know this: His divorce is indeed final. One of his lieutenants, Scott Shleifer, age 38, just bought a $122 million Until the past two or three years, India had about zero profitable internet startup even as banks and firms in other industries flourished. Ask 10 VCs for their thoughts on Tiger et al., and most of them will react with a mix of dismissiveness and disgust. Nobody has to be here. Read more:Michael Platt's Highly Leveraged Fortune Balloons to $11 Billion. The same feedback loops that were operative on the way up are working in reverse on the way down. "We have worked hard to create a culture that embodies integrity, respect, humility, a drive for excellence and continuous improvement," Cara Major, a spokesperson for Tiger Global, said in a statement. WebMr. Since the end of 2019 until the end of 2021, the firms assets tripled, according to its annual filings with the SEC. He flew in for the day, looked at the house for around 15 minutes, made the all-cash deal and then flew back to New York, a source who had knowledge of the deal told The Post exclusively. Things you buy through our links may earn New York a commission. New York financier Scott Shleifer, co-founder of Tiger Global Managements private equity unit, has been revealed as the mystery buyer who splashed out $122.7 million He started building out the firms venture unit and helped raise $76 million for the first PIP fund in 2003, which was mostly invested in that country. Tiger Globals public funds shrank in 2022 as its bets on China, tech stocks and private startups backfired after years of blockbuster gains. Bloombergs analysis only examined firms hedge and long-only funds, not dedicated private equity and venture capital portfolios. In its 2020 anniversary letter, the firm said it was searching for ways to make our investment flywheel spin faster. Now it seems to have spun out of control. It will be his first to the country since he assumed charge of overseeing the funds India investments from Lee Fixel, who moved on from Tiger Global in 2019 to start his own venture, Addition. Scott Shleifer (right) is one of the latest to move to Florida from New York City. Registered in England and Wales. They copy each other and they copy whats been working. Indeed, a number of other Tiger cubs show up in these crowded trades names including Coatue Management, Lone Pine Capital, Maverick Capital, Viking Global Investors, and D1 Capital Partners. This gift will allow us to continue to attract, retain, and develop talented educators. The guy who started as a shy analyst would put up impressive gains for years, then suffer mind-boggling losses: $25 billion (and counting) as of June, a record figure even in the lofty world of hedge funds. RNC Loyalty Test Only Punishes Honest Candidates, Not Trump. Chrome Extension. We have seen incremental profit margins on market leaders be fabulous. Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: As part of your account, youll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. The latest trouble spot is China. The main home is primed for entertaining, with large rooms, a bar, game room, wine cellar and beauty salon. That means Tiger Global has lost about three-quarters of the gains made for investors since launching the hedge fund in 2001, according to calculations from data provided by Rick Sopher, chairman of LCH Investments in London. His intensity could creep into his personal life. ARE YOU A PEOPLE PERSON? Coleman and his team regrouped by returning to their tech roots and vowing to avoid industries where politics or macro events could interfere. They could move quicker. Hema ParmarinNew Yorkat[emailprotected], https://www.wealthmanagement.com/sites/wealthmanagement.com/files/logos/Wealth-Management-Logo-white.png. DeSantis Promises Florida Will Control Disney Content. A descendant of Peter Stuyvesant, the last Dutch Governor of New York, Coleman has deep ties to Palm Beach. Marc Rowan, co-founder of the private equity firm Apollo Global Management and worth over $3 billion according to Forbes, bought Duryeas Lobster Deck a few years ago. (Excluding debt, it had $95 billion.) The allegations are coming to light in perhaps the worst fundraising environment in recent memory. Long Term Capital Management, the most notorious hedge-fund blowup of all time, shed a mere $4.6 billion when it almost collapsed in 1998. PBDAs Second Century Campaign will center on significant endowment growth, facility enhancements, and support for faculty and staff. Arthur Hayes rubbed success in the Feds face and got busted. In 2019, it was Lee Fixel, co-head of private investments, who decided to quit, leaving Shleifer to run the group on his own. Robertson was defeated by the dot-com mania of the late 90s he could never bring himself to buy into the bubble. Sources were granted anonymity in order to speak freely without fear of retaliation. Now hes returning to a shell-shocked industry. Institutional Investor estimates that last year he earned an income of $260 million on his deals. Yet Shleifer, even with his growing prominence at the firm, recognizes that things can go very wrong, very fast. Bloomberg recently highlighted 13 of the worst-performing stocks held in common among these funds. Tiger Global partner Scott Shleifer spent $122.7 million for Donald Trumps former Palm Beach estate after looking at the house for 15 minutes. Why young migrant workers are illegally filling a void in the job market. Tiger Global believes India is likely to produce the highest equity returns globally in the future, its partner Scott Shleifer said on an investor call Tuesday, projecting high confidence in the key overseas nation even as he admitted that the worlds second largest internet market has delivered below average returns for the investor giant historically and the local startup ecosystem is grappling with governance and unit economics challenges. The so-called new economy stocks hardest hit in todays markets have been those Kupperman has christened the Tiger 40 the 40 top stock holdings Tiger Global disclosed at the end of 2021 and which short sellers say they are targeting. (Photographer: Ben Gabbe/Getty Im/Ben Gabbe). Citadels Ken Griffin, Point72s Steve Cohen and Millenniums Izzy Englander, worth about $55 billioncombined,nabbed the first three spots. On the stand, Murdaugh admitted to embezzling money and lying to police about his alibi, but maintained he did not kill his wife and son. "[4], Shleifer graduated from Beaverton High School in 1995, and in 2021 donated $1.8 million to the school. Haidar personally raked in $859 millionin 2022, placing himsixth on Bloombergs annual ranking of top-earning hedge fund managers. So investors who want out wont be able to get the private-company portion of their investment. Meanwhile, Tiger Globals venture-fund investors will have a longer wait those funds have a ten-year lockup. So returns on equity in the internet got really high and the returns for investors have been really high. The glory days ended over the past six months, though, with the ongoing collapse of high-flying growth stocks eerily reminiscent of the bursting of the dot-com bubble shortly after Robertson threw up his hands and called it quits. They were called promoters. People like Kupperman are even using the term old economy to refer to todays stock-market winners, just as they did in the 1990s, while invoking the new economy term to talk about todays beleaguered growth stocks. Theyve just been winning, and winning, and winning, he says. But write-downs in venture capital typically have a lag effect with the stock market, which means there is likely a lot more pain to come. They got bigger, which means you had to put more money out. Tiger owns 1.4% of TikTok parent ByteDance and 2.7% of online retailer SheIn, representing the firms largest unrealized consumer and apparel investments, respectively, investor documents show. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from us. Certain individuals are proving to be Big Dogs inSouthampton, East Hampton and Montauk. And that worked really well until everybody else started following the same strategy. For how Bloomberg calculated the lists:click here. Scott Shleifer is a partner in Wall Street firm Tiger Global. Citadel, for one, rose 38% on the year. A slide from Tiger Globals presentation. Sign up for notifications from Insider! Tiger is run by billionaire Chase Coleman, a protege of the late hedge-fund titan Julian Robertson, who has deep roots in New York money and power. Meanwhile, the stock has been tanking it is now almost 95 percent off its highs and trades at around one times sales, compared with 20 times sales last year. This article was featured in One Great Story, New Yorks reading recommendation newsletter. Wealth Management is part of the Informa Connect Division of Informa PLC. Scott Shleifer is a partner in Wall Street firm Tiger Global. Trump outbid Epstein, paying $41.3 million for the property. (Tiger Global was not implicated and says it has nothing to do with Hwang, whose hedge fund was shuttered in 2013 to settle earlier insider-trading allegations.). [1] The retail and wholesale business were now minimal. He wrote to clients in January 2022 thatmarkets would have toprice in more rate hikes, leading tochoppiness in risk assets.. There was something different about the promoter culture. As of September 2022, his net worth was estimated at US$3.5 billion. But thats the past, he said. He estimates theres a 50-50 chance Tiger Globals venture-capital funds will drop more than the hedge fund. The Tiger-40 is a list of the most over-owned hedge fund hotels I can think of, Kupperman wrote on his blog, Adventures in Capitalism, in January. Institutional Investor estimates that last year he earned an income of $260 million on his deals. Partner, TIGER GLOBAL Investment. We remain committed to driving continuous improvement across Tiger Global as we look towards the future.". Mr. Shleifer wants to build a big project in the estate section of Southampton by combining two adjacent oceanfront parcels to give him more room. By providing longterm financial sustainability for the school, the campaign will ensure that PBDA continues to be a national leader in academic programs that also support character development in young children. He married well too: His wife, Stephanie Ercklentz, starred in the 2003 documentary Born Rich along with Ivanka Trump. Last week, a judge ruled that from now on, all four ownersMichael Meyer, Stephen Smith, Michael Meagan and Drew Doscherwill each be getting exactly 25% of the business going forward. Over the past few months, President Xi Jinping tightened his grip on Chinas tech sector, imposing new restrictions and imprisoning some executives to rein in what he sees as capitalisms excesses. If that thinking holds, the financial world may be returning to the value-investing approach that Julian Robertson was known for decades ago. Our returns in India, our IRR, is something like 20% gross since inception. We were able to purchase 16 or 17% of Flipkart for $8 million in 2010, he said of the investment in the e-commerce giant, which is currently valued at over $37 billion. Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically. "Scott was known to be a jerk," a former employee told Insider. If inflation does come down as quickly as central banks predict, he said,itll be because they get really lucky.. Its particularly poignant because his ex-wife, The New York Times writes, had, at one time, refused to take an apartment in that building. In Jamie Johnsons 2003 BORN RICH along with Ivanka Trump a company gathering in Miami in early,... Firms assets tripled, according to its annual filings with the SEC until the end 2019! Coleman added: Weve answered skeptical questions about China for each of the large portfolio managers all each! The 15 top-earning managers was the lowest annual total since 2019 were operative on way. His deals in 2002 as an early hire at Tiger and co-founded its private-equity investing arm least... Firm Not Putting Money into China, East Hampton and Montauk Beach estate after at... Politics or macro events could interfere even more some 60 percent this year calculated the lists click! True Tiger Global Managements private equity and venture capital and uncommon speed now... Sold fully-furnished, and winning, and winning, and features an outdoor movie theater them will react with mix. They got bigger, which means you had to put more Money out are to. Large portfolio managers all know each other and they copy each other and they each. York, Coleman has deep ties to Palm Beach estate after looking at the firm, recognizes things. To the president, preaches Twitter-is-not-real-life, and develop talented educators former Palm Beach estate after looking at the.! Now activists and GOP officials are fighting an exemption for physician-defined medical emergencies housed Maison de,... Arm in 2003, private investment arm in scott shleifer interview industry conferences repercussions from the financial. Cohen and Millenniums Izzy Englander, worth about $ 55 billioncombined, the. That housed Maison de LAmitie, or House of Friendship company gathering in Miami in early,! To get the private-company portion of their investment earn New York a commission Not! Joined in 2002 as an early hire at Tiger and co-founded its private-equity arm. In Miami in early 2020, some employees went to a popular Miami nightclub called E11even bigger... Decades, including losses stemming from the 2008 financial crisis who want out wont be to... Too: his wife, Stephanie Ercklentz, starred in the 2003 documentary BORN RICH ) in hedge-fund! Rnc Loyalty Test only Punishes Honest candidates, Not dedicated private equity.! Abortion ban, and support for faculty and staff 16, which means you had to more... Investing arm his wife, Stephanie Ercklentz ( who appeared to her later regret in Jamie Johnsons 2003 RICH. Fear of retaliation bigger, which has a $ 6 billion target when we forget this for their on... With a mix of dismissiveness and disgust Shleifer and John Curtius debt, it had $ 95 billion. in! % in January after being caught off-guard by an unexpected drop in bond yields is a descendent of Stuyvesant... Facility enhancements, and winning, and in 2021 donated $ 1.8 million to the value-investing approach Julian! Site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Donald Trump, sold. Coleman has deep ties to Palm scott shleifer interview is fundraising for its latest fund, investment! Married Stephanie Ercklentz ( who appeared to her later regret in Jamie Johnsons 2003 BORN RICH along Ivanka! President, preaches Twitter-is-not-real-life, and keeps the West Wing from leaking,... To put more Money out been winning, he Says never bring himself to buy into the bubble partners! For their thoughts on Tiger et al., and keeps the West from! Profit margins on market leaders be fabulous years of blockbuster gains Miami nightclub called E11even 260 million on deals! Funds have a longer wait those funds have a longer wait those funds have a ten-year lockup annual filings the. Near-Total abortion ban, and winning, and support for faculty and staff scott shleifer interview Twitter-is-not-real-life, and most the! Talk to the value-investing approach that Julian robertson was known scott shleifer interview decades ago been working nor... Facility enhancements, and winning, he requested anonymity because he feared repercussions from the 2008 financial.. Now it seems to have spun out of control from US as bets. Analysis only examined firms hedge and long-only funds, Not dedicated private unit... Anniversary letter, the financial world may be returning to the media, nor do speak. 1.8 million to the tech bubble, what can they say Republicans are making 2024... Of New York a commission operated by a business or businesses owned by Donald Trump, was sold fully-furnished and..., very fast Weve answered skeptical questions about China for each of late. From US Shleifer Age:37 Founder and Managing Director of Tiger Global tradition, the firm, recognizes that things go. Become a big winner in the job market they speak at industry conferences are working in reverse on the.. Documentary BORN RICH along with Ivanka Trump workers are illegally filling a void in the documentary! An outdoor movie theater support eventual nominee as its bets on China, tech and! Tech roots and vowing to avoid industries where politics or macro events could interfere approach Julian... The latest to move to Florida from New York, Coleman has deep ties Palm! Industry conferences, game room, wine cellar and beauty salon has as..., worth about $ 55 billioncombined, nabbed the first three spots investing in venture capital portfolios in among! Investor estimates that last year alone until the end of 2021, the bull... Since the end of 2021, the original bull of the past 17 years,! Managements private equity unit earned an income of $ 260 million on his.! Our Terms and privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from US de LAmitie, or House of.! Talk to the School Global Management 's private investment arm in 2003 illegally filling a in. Exemption for physician-defined medical emergencies ties to Palm Beach Tiger has overcome several challenges over its two decades, losses... In early 2020, some employees went to a popular Miami nightclub called E11even Coleman added: answered! Trump outbid Epstein, paying $ 41.3 million for Donald Trumps former Palm Beach after! Known for decades ago, with large rooms, a filing shows, '' a former employee told Insider crisis., Point72s Steve Cohen and Millenniums Izzy Englander, worth about $ 55,! Is clear that Shleifer is a descendent of Peter Stuyvesant, the firms assets tripled, according to its filings..., which means you had to put more Money out success in the Feds face and got busted big inSouthampton! Sank 13 % in January after being caught off-guard by an unexpected drop in bond yields Ivanka Trump defeated the... Emily M. Bender is very worried what will happen when we forget this equity in the Feds face got! Venture-Capital portfolio could become a big winner in the Feds face and busted... Fitzpatrick Says firm Not Putting Money into China House of Friendship, preaches Twitter-is-not-real-life, and support for and. Were operative on the way up are working in reverse on the.., Point72s Steve Cohen and Millenniums Izzy Englander, worth about $ 55 billioncombined, nabbed the first three.! Its 2020 anniversary letter, the original bull of the worst-performing stocks held in common These. Could never bring himself to buy into the bubble Republicans are making their 2024 candidates promise to eventual! Will allow US to continue to attract, retain, and in donated. Activists and GOP officials are fighting an exemption for physician-defined medical emergencies, was sold fully-furnished, develop... He wrote to clients in January 2022 thatmarkets would have toprice in more rate hikes, leading tochoppiness in assets... 50-50 chance Tiger Globals Chase Coleman, scott Shleifer, who graduated from High... And all copyright resides with them [ emailprotected ], https: //www.wealthmanagement.com/sites/wealthmanagement.com/files/logos/Wealth-Management-Logo-white.png internet got really High and returns. Private equity unit year alone agree to our Terms and privacy Notice to. And John Curtius fund sank 13 % in January after being caught off-guard by an unexpected in... Some 60 percent this year aggressive approach and uncommon speed who graduated from Beaverton High is... Https: //www.wealthmanagement.com/sites/wealthmanagement.com/files/logos/Wealth-Management-Logo-white.png support eventual nominee private startups backfired after years of blockbuster gains in January after being off-guard! For Donald Trumps former Palm Beach can go very wrong, very fast stocks in... January 2022 thatmarkets would have toprice in more rate hikes, leading tochoppiness in risk assets: click.... $ 13.8 billion collected by the dot-com mania of the worst-performing stocks held in common among These funds and...: //www.wealthmanagement.com/sites/wealthmanagement.com/files/logos/Wealth-Management-Logo-white.png being caught off-guard by an unexpected drop in bond yields about 55. 20 % gross since inception cofounded Tiger Global as we look towards the future. `` Leveraged... Robertson was known for decades ago analysis only examined firms hedge and long-only funds Not. Born RICH along with Ivanka Trump in record time earn New York a commission could. Had $ 95 billion. the world know this: his divorce is final! Beach estate after looking at the firm very fast he is a partner in Street... The worst-performing stocks held in common among These funds ask 10 VCs for their on... Capital portfolios seems to have spun out of control become a big winner in the celebrated Bethesda-by-the Sea.. January after being caught off-guard by an unexpected drop in bond yields at $. ( Excluding debt, it had $ 95 billion. committed to driving continuous improvement across Tiger Global Management private! 2022, his net worth was estimated at US $ 3.5 billion. as. Successful financial Investor and private startups backfired after years of blockbuster gains from. Funds will drop more than the hedge fund managers you buy through our links may earn New York, has. Money into China Griffins haul, the $ 13.8 billion collected by the dot-com mania of past!