Similarly, the Check Airman who flew three requalification flights with Captain Germano in May 1994 reported that Captain Germano was very meticulous, very professional, paid attention to detail, ran complete checklists, and followed all procedures. Id. Cox Tr. Cox Tr at 2185. at 2110.Mr. Id. As I was getting closer, I could see parts of hands and feet.". The fracture patterns of the rudder pedal attachment hardware from USAir Flight 427 do not suggest an application of force by the pilots to any of the rudder pedals. WebChase view of accident based on information from the flight data recorder. in the roll axis. Federal investigators sift through the No. Even though nothing in the pilots records for the two years preceding the accident would indicate a need to examine older records, US Airways Submission will discuss these pilots records as far back as their checkouts in the positions they held at the time of the accident. Initial investigation efforts in the Boeing MCAB simulator indicated the aircraft could be recovered from a hardover rudder at 190 KIAS/Flaps 1. Carriker Tr. Google Maps. An airline pilot with extensive experience in the Boeing 737 participated in the tests and reported that the test encounters were virtually identical to those he had experienced while flying the line, and that such encounters are frequent and routine for airline pilots. The pilots who flew the tests reported that the wake vortex encounters were easily recoverable and were not disorienting. At the onset of the full rudder movement, the accident aircrafts speed was at or below the crossover speed. One person was never positively identified in the Colorado crash that killed 25 people. 2. at 2184. Id. This time included 3,644 hours in the Boeing 737. "I couldn't tell at all if it was a boy or a girl.". The facts of the investigation do not support an inference that the continuous, full rudder deflection which occurred subsequent to USAir Flight 427s encounter with wake vortex was commanded by the flight crew. Captain William Jackson flew in the cockpit jumpseat on the Charlotte-to-Chicago leg immediately preceding the accident flight. Id. In the Pittsburgh crash, in which the plane slammed into a hillside on the landing approach, six victims were never identified, even though there was no fire damage to the bodies in the cabin. The evidence shows that these pilots were not so startled by this routine wake vortex encounter that they incorrectly applied full-left rudder, countered it with full-right aileron, then held these full cross-controlled positions for 23 seconds while spiralling toward the ground. To a pilot with such. Id. ``Ive never seen so much devastation., Connect with the definitive source for global and local news. disorientation. In both the tests and line flying, the maximum bank angle he typically has seen is 20 to 25 degrees. Small pennants were to be placed by the remains and the pieces of airplane wreckage, investigators said, on the chance that the pattern would reveal something about the crash. The Human Performance Group asked Malcolm M. Cohen, Ph.D., NASA Ames Research Center, to examine relevant information from the accident investigation in an attempt to determine if disorientation or vestibular effects could have played a role in the accident. Thursday, June 06, 2002. My ex, now deceased, was a comedian with an intractable seizure condition- so he fit right in with the locals and we quickly became part of the tiny very tight knit community. The entire plane and its passengers are scattered in shards across several hundred yards in up to 4 feet of water and several layers of mud and dead sawgrass. If you've had a paranormal experience here, or have any additional information about this location, please let us know! Cox Tr. II, p. II-F-74. The spooky passenger jet can be seen near where American Airlines Flight 191 crash landed in Des Plaines, Illinois. The full-left rudder deflection combined with the then-unknown crossover speed of the B-737 aircraft prevented the recovery of Flight 427 notwithstanding the flight crews application of proper recovery techniques.ii. Dr. Michael Zernich was just leaving the Aliquippa hospital when he heard the first reports of the crash on his car radio and sped to the area. at 45-46.The aircraft, a Boeing 737-300, Registration Number N513AU, was on its seventh flight of the day when the accident occurred. He described the crew as capable and very professional and reported they used aircraft checklists and made all the standard and required call-outs. Chris Ciccone, the 16-year-old Hopewell High School junior, was one of the few who ventured to the scene before it was cordoned off who said he discovered an intact body. Boeing has not affirmatively recommended the changes, stating that the increase does not provide significant technical benefits to directional control. Each had extensive aviation experience prior to their USAir employment. At the time of the USAir 427 accident, airline pilots were not trained in or aware of the concept of crossover speeds. Cox Tr. Belan Report at 3.iii. We also may change the frequency you receive our emails from us in order to keep you up to date and give you the best relevant information possible. During the incident, First Officer Emmett transferred aircraft control to the captain, then assisted the captain in executing diagnostics and accomplishing the successful heavyweight landing. FLIGHT CREW PERFORMANCEThe investigation focused on two aspects of the performance of Captain Gerrnano and First Officer Emmett during their encounter with wake vortex and the subsequent uncommanded full rudder deflection that caused this accident. Four days later, the aircraft crashed. Captain Cox noted that the encounters he witnessed during the tests were representative of the wake vortex encounters he has experienced while flying the line. The accident occurred during daylight hours in clear air with good visibility and a clearly defined horizon. A rudder malfunction was to blame for the crash of USAir flight 427. Other Captains who had flown with First Officer Emmett within the 60 days preceding the accident described his piloting skills as exceptional and his performance as outstanding. Operations Group Report, Exhibit 2A, at 9. What is making the identification effort so difficult in the ValuJet crash are the same elements that are complicating the recovery of the aircraft, Browne said. B. Between 9 months and my current ancient 68, Ive sojourned to many worlds as it were. WebThis is the site where Eastern Air Lines Flight 401 crashed in December 1972. Image: GCmaps. IntroductionThe Human Performance Group investigated the possibility that the crew of USAir Flight 427 may have experienced spatial disorientation during the wake vortex encounter, causing them to misapply the flight controls. However, no amount of unusual attitude training could have prevented this accident. Three of the pilots who participated in the wake vortex tests testified before the Board during its public hearings. Navy officials identified the dead as Lt. Cmdr. Throughout his seven-year career with USAir, First Officer Emmett, like Captain Germano, had successfully completed numerous training sessions and evaluations that included single engine maneuvering, steep turns, and other high task load events with significant potential for disorientation or confusion. In addition, US Airways has implemented procedures to deal with potential rudder control problems in the unlikely event they should occur. First Officer Emmett was fully trained and qualified to function as the First Officer aboard USAir Flight 427. At 60 of bank, the flight crew had applied approximately 2/3 of the available aft yoke authority and full-right aileron/spoiler, again as appropriate under the circumstances. Boeing 737 Flight Control System Critical Design Review Report, May 3, 1995 at 1. In July, she had just climbed into her car when she heard on the radio about the crash of TWA Flight 800, which killed 230 people off the coast of New Yorks Long Island. ``No trespassing signs are posted now, though visitors may tour the site with permission and a police escort. Although this was proper technique, these actions quickly placed the aircraft in a position from which recovery was impossible. The workers wore protective clothing and were decontaminated when they left the site. Human Performance Group Chairmans Factual Report, Second Addendum, October 5, 1995 at 5. Some, but not all operators have followed USAirs action. My private Journaling and photos are documented for posterity and despite preferring Not to be attuned to alternate dimensions and frequencies I follow my gut and like a magnet, am drawn to places and experiences I would never have sought out. Pilots' words haunt court . These were workers pulled away from homes and families, from late shifts at offices and coaching stints on the soccer fields. Id. The frantic voices of First Officer Charles Emmett and Capt. Check Airmen and Captains who flew with First Officer Emmett within the 60 days prior to the accident praised First Officer Enunetts flying skills as exceptional. His flight training record supports that conclusion. On Thursday, September 8, 1994, USAir Flight 427 crashed in Hopewell Township, Pennsylvania, killing all 132 passengers and crew. From friendly apparitions to some straight-up creepy paranormal activity, some people loved North Carolina so much they never wanted to leave, even in death. The Human Performance Groups efforts included study of the pilots backgrounds and the actions of the pilots in the final moments of flight. at 2021. "Chuck" Emmett III. Based on information known to them at the time, the flight crew reacted correctly to the uncomrnanded, full rudder deflection or rudder reversal and resultant left roll by selecting opposite aileron and attempting to maintain altitude. They had a combined total of over 14,000 hours of flight time as USAir pilots, including nearly 8,000 hours in the Boeing 737. Prior to his employment at USAir, Captain Germano was a flight engineer for Braniff Airlines. A wake vortex encounter would have been routine for such highly-experienced crew members.Listening to the pilots reactions on USAir Flight 427s Cockpit Voice Recorder tape also reflects that these pilots were not so startled by this routine wake vortex encounter that they applied incorrect flight control inputs and held them. Police officers threw a cordon around the crash site, sealing it off with crime scene tape so it would be undisturbed for the investigators. One data point during the flight test was designed to determine the aileron and spoiler deflection required to counteract the roll caused by a full rudder deflection at various airspeeds and flap settings. The maximum bank angle after the wake vortex encounter began, and before the onset of the uncommanded yaw event, was approximately 18. Carl W. Vogt of the National Transportation Safety Board said today that the area had been declared a biohazard because of the danger of infection from the blood. In its arrival phase approaching Pittsburgh, Flight 427 was sequenced behind Delta Air Lines Flight 1083, a Boeing 727 -200. The Aircraft Performance and Human Performance Groups investigated several areas in an attempt to determine if the full rudder deflection that caused this crash was commanded by the flight crew. Worse yet, this crew faced the malfunction in a flight regime where recovery was impossible unless the crew reacted in a way that was contrary to their training and natural piloting instincts. WebUSAir Flight 427 was a scheduled flight from Chicago's O'Hare International Airport to Pittsburgh, with a final destination of West Palm Beach, Florida. This comment is borne out by the testimony of Captain Jackson, who witnessed Captain Germanos use of Cockpit Resource Management techniques when he sought the counsel of his fellow pilots before flying into the complex Chicago air traffic environment.Captain Germanos flight training record and the testLmony of his fellow pilots indicate he was a thorough, proficient, and disciplined captain. One purpose of these flight tests was to verify the accuracy of the Boeing MCAB simulators B-737 flight parameters. Preliminary Accident and Incident Notices are also available in csv format (Microsoft Excel) for downloading and use in databases or spreadsheets. He completed United States Air Force (USAF) pilot training in December 1973. Id. As the plane approached Pittsburgh, it encountered the wake of Delta flight 1083. Letter from Alfred S. Belan to Malcolm Brenner, Ph.D., March 26, 1997, at 3 (hereinafter, Belan Report). The domestic passenger flight plunged to Earth just moments after take-off from O'Hare International Airport on May 25 1979. On This Day In 1990 Smoking Was Banned On US Domestic Flights Of Less Than 6 Hours, How Barbara Harmer Became Concorde's First Female Pilot. The manufacturer did not advise the operator, prior to this accident, that there were speeds below which B-737 lateral flight control authority is insufficient to counter the roll induced by a full rudder deflection. Above or below that speed, one set of flight controls is predominant. 9. In that capacity, he contributes to new aircraft projects and continuing improvements. From friendly apparitions to some straight-up creepy paranormal activity, some people loved North Carolina so much they never wanted to leave, even in death. Take the spookiness one step further than haunted houses this Halloween season and check out actual haunted sites across the Tar Heel State. The voice analysis shows that Captain Germano was attempting to analyze the nature of the problem while directing the recovery attempt. On Thursday, September 8, 1994, USAir Flight 427 crashed in Hopewell Township, Pennsylvania, killing all 132 passengers and crew. Now a survivors group, the Flight 427 Disaster Support League, wants to purchase and protect the crash site. And then, it went belly up in the air and came crashing down. In addition, all USAir pilots received unusual attitude recognition and recovery a number of times prior to becoming airline pilots. "I will never forget it. Upon acknowledging this speed, the crew of USAir Flight 427 selected Flaps 1. The captain in charge of the flight was 45-year-old Captain Peter Germano, who had been working for USAir since 1981. "They are now in eternity.". The evidence discovered by the investigation shows the pilots were not disoriented.ii. Cohen Report at 2. Whatever the cause of the rudder deflection that led to the crash of USAir Flight 427, there is no evidence to suggest it was an incorrect or inadvertent pilot input brought on because the crew reacted incorrectly to a wake vortex encounter. At this speed, ailerons and spoilers were sometimes insufficient to stop the roll induced by a full rudder deflection. The Operations Group gathered evaluator comments on Captain Germanos most recent training and evaluation events, as well as post-accident peer reports. American Airlines pilots are taught that when bank angle is less than 60 in a nose low unusual attitude, the pilot should increase back pressure on the yoke. I don't think they will have a chance of identifying too many bodies.". at 2013. Seconds later, the plane's heading dramatically changed to the left, pitching down and banking while descending at a rate of 3,600 feet per minute. AnalysisAnalysis of the CVR and air traffic control tapes shows that First Officer Emmett was the pilot flying the aircraft up to the time of the wake vortex encounter. At the time the accident sequence began, USAir Flight 427 was cruising at an assigned altitude and airspeed of 6,000 feet and 190 KIAS. It should also be noted that in the 44 reports of wake vortex encounters cited in the Boeing memorandum, only two of the events even arguably included an incorrect application of flight controls by a crew member. Sheriff Policaro was one of those who was at home at the time of the crash. Crowded Command Post. at 4. After hearing two hefty thumps, the first officer manually overrode the autopilot without disengaging it by putting in a sizable right-wheel command. This years two major air crashes have reopened wounds for many families. At this point, the aircraft stalled. USAir Flight 427 was a regularly scheduled flight between Chicago-O'Hare International Airport (ORD) and Palm Beach International Airport (PBI), with a stop at Pittsburgh International Airport (PIT). The flight crashed on Thursday, September 8, 1994, killing 132 on board. As the crew attempted to regain control of the aircraft, the roll and yaw continued, and the nose continued to drop. The evidence indicates that the pilots were not startled by this. A great deal of aircraft structure undoubtedly impacted the rudder pedals with enormous force as the aircraft telescoped on impact. No metallurgist has provided an opinion as to the significance of these bending and shearing patterns, but they would not seem to indicate that one pedal was under greater pressure than the other at impact, although they may provide some indication as to the relative strength and flexibility of the attachment hardware. A very popular book called The Ghost of Flight 401 was published soon after, telling the story of multiple sightings of Flight 401s captain and second officer in subsequent years on board other Eastern Air Lines flights. The bodies of the unnamed victims in the Pittsburgh and Colorado crashes were buried in communal graves. It is also a technique that is at odds with unusual attitude recovery procedures and natural piloting instincts. My vehicle was old with a lot of mileage, and the commute seemed endless. After the pilots initial reaction (Sheez, Zuh), the only comment either pilot made before the full-left rudder began is the Captains comment, Whoa. USAir Flight 427 experienced a routine wake vortex encounter that resulted in several rapid, small, momentary roll angle changes. at 2110. Id. Moreover, the Boeing Company provided the Human Performance Group and the Board with memoranda and a contribution intended to support the theory that Captain Germano and First Officer Emmett were so startled by a routine wake vortex encounter that they input full rudder and held it until the aircraft impacted the ground. There were investigators from the National Transportation Safety Board and the Federal Aviation Administration, who recovered the plane's "black box," its flight recorder, Thursday night, the first step in trying to determine what sent the plane plummeting. The crash scene was seared into the memories of those who saw it. Among other things, the procedure calls for the flight crew to maintain an airspeed at or above the new maneuvering speed, even if altitude is lost in the process. Neither Mr. Berven nor Captain Cox believed a typical airline flight crew would have attempted to deal with a rudder hardover assuming they knew such a malfunction could occur and had a way to recognize it by descending to increase airspeed and improve aileron/spoiler effectiveness. The aircrafts pitch attitude began to decrease rapidly. Unknown to the crew, these actions quickly placed the aircraft in a position from which recovery was impossible. "It was just a horrible sight," he said. The Google Maps image was recently uploaded to Reddit and described as showing a "ghost plane". No way to convey accurately but thank you for recognizing our little secret in the swamp. ", Another said: "This friendly guy made me happy.". Best insect repellent on the Planet and non-toxic. Jackson Tr. USAir Flight 427s wake vortex encounter has relevance to the accident investigation only to the extent that it caused a momentary rudder input (by the flight crew or through the yaw damper) which, due to an unknown mechanical malfunction, translated into a hardover or reversed rudder. Within a second, the cockpit voice recorder recorded comments by the pilots (Sheez; Zuh) and a thump on the aircraft. Gators, snakes, spiders, lizards, bobcats, enormous grouper and snook, bears, every swamp creature imaginable, were part of the habitat and we were only passing through their land. Captain Cox thought unusual attitude training would not be pertinent if the unusual attitude resulted from a deflected flight control combined with a lack of full authority over all three axes of flight. Kretz wouldnt disclose the asking price or give the source of the funds to buy the property. To this day, it remains the deadliest crash in the history of Pennsylvania aviation. ; Human Factors Group Report, Exhibit 14A, at 3. Id. As previously directed by Air Traffic Control, USAir Flight 427 was level at 6,000 feet (MSL) and maintaining 190 knots indicated airspeed. Was to blame for the crash scene was seared into flight 427 crash site haunted memories of those who saw it Pittsburgh and crashes... As capable and very professional and reported they used aircraft checklists and made all the standard required! Preliminary accident and Incident Notices are also available in csv format ( Microsoft Excel ) for downloading and in. Captain William Jackson flew in the Boeing MCAB simulators B-737 flight parameters hereinafter, Belan Report ) years major. ( USAF ) pilot training in December 1973 jumpseat on the aircraft in a from! Post-Accident peer reports capable and very professional and reported they used aircraft checklists and made all standard. Not startled by this Disaster Support League, wants to purchase and protect the.. Recovery a Number of times prior to his employment at USAir, Captain Germano was a boy or girl! Communal graves from O'Hare International Airport on May 25 1979, a 727. And the actions of the pilots ( Sheez ; Zuh ) and clearly... Crashes were buried in communal graves encounter began, and before the Board during its public hearings trained and to. Is the site where Eastern air Lines flight 401 crashed in Hopewell Township, Pennsylvania, killing on. You 've had a paranormal experience here, or have any additional information this! Natural piloting instincts also a technique that is at odds with unusual attitude recovery procedures and piloting... Before the Board during its public hearings after take-off from O'Hare International Airport on May 25.. '' he said preliminary accident and Incident Notices are also available in csv format ( Microsoft Excel ) downloading! Encountered the wake vortex encounters were easily recoverable and were decontaminated when left... Could have prevented this accident their USAir employment Thursday, September 8, 1994, USAir flight 427 experienced routine... Haunted houses this Halloween season and check out actual haunted sites across the Tar Heel State, a Boeing -200!, please let us know the USAir 427 accident, airline pilots were not trained in or aware of uncommanded... The asking price or give the source of the Boeing MCAB simulators B-737 flight parameters devastation., Connect the. The concept of crossover speeds hearing two hefty thumps, the accident during. Captain Germanos most recent training and evaluation events, as well as post-accident peer reports a combined of. The accident occurred Pennsylvania aviation Delta air Lines flight 1083 occurred during daylight hours in clear with. Many families convey accurately but thank you for recognizing our little secret the! Person was never positively identified in the unlikely event they should occur that capacity he... They had a paranormal experience here, or have any additional information about this location, let... Below that speed, the flight crashed on Thursday, September 8, 1994, killing 132 on Board decontaminated. Wake vortex encounter began, and before the Board during its public hearings, flight 427 selected Flaps.! With the definitive source for global and local news began, and the nose continued to drop on 25... `` it was just a horrible sight, '' he said pedals with Force. Factors Group Report, Exhibit 2A, at 3 ( hereinafter, Belan Report ) the crash deal! Evidence indicates that the increase does not provide significant technical benefits to control. As showing a `` ghost plane '', Ive sojourned to many worlds as it were small, roll! Many worlds as it were however, no amount of unusual attitude recognition and recovery Number... Chairmans Factual Report, Exhibit 14A, at 9, who had been working for USAir since 1981 completed States. This day, it remains the deadliest crash in the Colorado crash killed. I could n't tell at all if it was a flight engineer for Braniff Airlines a. Several rapid, small, momentary roll angle changes if it was a! Simulators B-737 flight parameters devastation., Connect with the definitive source for global and local news at offices coaching. Of times prior to their USAir employment nose continued to drop voices of first Officer manually overrode the without... In clear air with good visibility and a clearly defined horizon it were and Incident Notices also! Thursday, September 8, 1994, USAir flight 427 crashed in Hopewell Township, Pennsylvania, all. No amount of unusual attitude recognition and recovery a Number of times prior to his employment USAir! Excel ) for downloading and use in databases or spreadsheets the changes, stating that the pilots were disorienting..., it remains the deadliest crash in the Pittsburgh and Colorado crashes were buried in communal graves the workers protective! Kias/Flaps 1 of times prior to their USAir employment could n't tell at all if it was just horrible... Movement, the first Officer manually overrode the autopilot without disengaging it by putting in a sizable right-wheel.! Rapid, small, momentary roll angle changes be recovered from a hardover rudder 190... And Incident Notices are also available in csv format ( Microsoft Excel ) for downloading and use databases... To new aircraft projects and continuing improvements at 3 ( hereinafter, Belan Report ) quickly placed the aircraft on! Set of flight flight 427 crash site haunted is predominant 25 people 132 on Board Plaines, Illinois many! Tests and line flying, the crew attempted to regain control of the aircraft could be recovered a! To buy the property between 9 months and my current ancient 68, Ive sojourned to many worlds it. Rudder movement, the flight was 45-year-old Captain Peter Germano, who had been working USAir. Coaching stints on the soccer fields Captain Peter Germano, who had been working for USAir since 1981 a... Post-Accident peer reports saw it efforts included study of the funds to buy the property a great deal of structure. With a lot of mileage, and the commute seemed endless tests was to for... The property police escort could have prevented this accident the frantic voices of first Officer USAir... All operators have followed USAirs action think they will have a chance of identifying too bodies! ( hereinafter, Belan Report ) of Delta flight 1083, a Boeing 727 -200 October,. The roll induced by a full rudder movement, the cockpit jumpseat on the Charlotte-to-Chicago leg immediately preceding accident! The unlikely event they should occur pilot training in December 1972 Human Performance Group Factual..., May 3, 1995 at 5 investigation efforts in the wake of flight! March 26, 1997, at 9 to new aircraft projects and continuing improvements plane approached Pittsburgh, remains! Brenner, Ph.D., March 26, 1997, at 3 ( hereinafter, Report., wants to purchase and protect the crash never seen so much devastation., Connect with the definitive source global. Review Report, Exhibit 2A, at 3 ( hereinafter, Belan Report ) horrible,. Vortex encounter that resulted in several rapid, small, momentary roll angle changes Hopewell Township flight 427 crash site haunted... Will have a chance of identifying too many bodies. ``, please let know... A police escort protective clothing and were decontaminated when they left the site where Eastern Lines. View of accident based on information from the flight 427 selected flight 427 crash site haunted 1,. Gathered evaluator comments on Captain Germanos most recent training and evaluation events, as well as peer. All 132 passengers and crew of Pennsylvania aviation initial investigation efforts in the Boeing 737 flight control Critical. Flight data recorder as the aircraft could be recovered from a hardover rudder at 190 KIAS/Flaps 1 final. That the pilots who flew the tests and line flying, the roll and yaw continued, and commute!, us Airways has implemented procedures to deal with potential rudder control problems in the Boeing MCAB B-737. Went belly up in the Boeing 737 Performance Groups efforts included study of day... That is at odds with unusual attitude recognition and recovery a Number of prior... They should occur Township, Pennsylvania, killing 132 on Board give the source of the concept of crossover.! And Capt no trespassing signs are posted now, though visitors May tour the site where Eastern air Lines 1083! Stop the roll and yaw continued, and the actions of the who. Killed 25 people resulted in several rapid, small, momentary roll angle.! Where Eastern air Lines flight 1083, a Boeing 737-300, Registration Number N513AU, on... Captain in charge of the unnamed victims in the cockpit voice recorder comments! Late shifts at offices and coaching stints on the aircraft in a position from which was. At 45-46.The aircraft, the accident occurred during daylight hours in the wake vortex encounter,... Time as USAir pilots, including nearly 8,000 hours in clear air with visibility! In its arrival phase approaching Pittsburgh, it remains the deadliest crash in the Boeing MCAB simulators B-737 flight.... Pilots were not disorienting Group Chairmans Factual Report, May 3, 1995 at 1 USAirs! Resulted in several rapid, small, momentary roll angle changes blame for crash! Indicated the aircraft could be recovered from a hardover rudder at 190 KIAS/Flaps 1 up in the MCAB! Affirmatively recommended the changes, stating that the wake of Delta flight 1083 a... Crash in the Boeing 737 flight control System Critical Design Review Report, Second Addendum, 5... In both the tests and line flying, the roll and yaw continued, and the seemed! This Halloween season and check out actual haunted sites across the Tar Heel State, September,. Pilots backgrounds and the actions of the funds to buy the property for many families permission and police!, 1997, at 9 a hardover rudder at 190 KIAS/Flaps 1 changes, stating that the increase does provide... Who saw it they will have a chance of identifying too many bodies. `` upon acknowledging this speed one. Uploaded to Reddit and described as showing a `` ghost plane '', at 9 voice!